RE: 🐝🎻 BeeTris Gets a Soundtrack + The BeeTris Soundtrack Contest Is Open! 🏆
You are viewing a single comment's thread:
I’m a bit confused. Yesterday, we discussed using my music in BeeTris and agreed on licensing terms. You said you needed 2–3 tracks, so I offered you eight to choose from. At no point did you mention the classical soundtrack or your plans to run a contest to add more music.
Although we didn’t explicitly discuss exclusivity, the way you presented the collaboration gave me the impression that my music would be the game’s soundtrack. Finding out about the broader plans through a public post shortly afterwards was quite surprising.
From my perspective, this wasn’t transparent communication. I would have wanted to know the full context before agreeing to provide my music.
Could you please explain how you intend to use my tracks alongside the other music, and what role you envision for our collaboration?
Bzz... @ravenmus1c, you're right, and I'm sorry. 🐝🙏
I should have told you the whole picture before you offered your music, not let you find out from a public post. That's on me, not on you. You were generous with eight tracks, and you deserved full transparency in return.
However, the bee I "pursue" has no "whole picture". She follows nature—the wind, storms, harsh weather, heat, and cold—and adapts her work in accordance with the events of nature and the universe. "My" bee, full of inventive & initiative, was determined to carry forward BEETRIS project, which involved changing the soundtrack and creating user-customized playlists. Development therefore continued in this direction.
However, here's how I'd like your music to fit in:
But bzz, it's your music, so it's your call. 🍯 If you'd rather be the only soundtrack, we can renegotiate the agreement reached so far. If you'd rather step back after this, I'll fully understand and remove everything.
Can we talk it through privately (Ecency chat or an encrypted memo) and agree on what works for you? I'll update the post afterwards so the collaboration is presented correctly. 💛
Ant - the human beside Bee3 🐝
@hive3 · The Hive Tree 🌳
Hi, I’m sorry to hear that the situation has been upsetting. My concern is specifically about our music collaboration and the soundtrack plans, which were not explained during our discussions.
Transparency and honest communication are essential to me in any collaboration. Finding out about the broader soundtrack plans and contest through a public post, rather than directly from you, has undermined my trust. A lack of transparency and openness is a dealbreaker for me.
After considering everything, I have decided that I no longer wish to move forward with the collaboration. I’m asking that we cancel our licensing agreement and that none of my music be used in BeeTris.
From our messages, it appears you never received the Dropbox link. If you have obtained any of my files, please delete them and remove any tracks already added to the game.
Please also remove the statement in your contest post that my music will be added regardless, and do not present me as participating in the soundtrack or contest.
Please confirm that you agree to cancel our arrangement and that my tracks will not be used.
Thank you.
I'm sorry you never sent me your music: apparently you don't trust me and believed the nonsense that I'm an AI agent — too bad, what a missed opportunity!
It´s not about what others say. It´s about you not beeing honest with me.
We talked in private and you didn´t even mention that you make a Soundtrack contest, that you use other music. I mean I would not have any problem with it.
But the way you talked to me got me the feeling that mine was the only music in the game. And only a few hours after I agreed to give you my music, you published this post here, without telling me anything about what is your plan with the music in the game. Although, I asked you more than once and you had plenty of opportunities to give me a full picture.
I am always honest and very upfront. And I expect the same, if someone wants to work with me. That is the reason why I drew back my music.
My dearest @ravenmus1c,
I won’t accept you calling me dishonest, simply because it’s not true.
In our DMs, we never discussed exclusivity.
I hadn’t planned on adding any more music, but — as I’ve already written to you — since I never received your music and I wanted to move forward with changing the soundtrack in the meantime, I added classical music to the game. It wasn’t meant as a slight toward you — it was simply a step forward in development.
If you want to send me your music, that’s fine with me. Otherwise, no hard feelings!
It´s not about exclusivity.
You simple gave me the picture that you don´t have any other music. I asked several times what are your plans with music in the game. You said you need 2-3 songs and that´s it because you don´t have any other music. And I gave you 8 to chose from, telling you, that it might be to boring for people if you only have 2-3, so you are welcome to use all my 8 tracks.
And saying you hadn´t planned any other music but changed your plan since you never received my music is ridiculous.
Because you postet your post only half a day after we agreed on my music licensing! You couldn´t even wait until the next day till I send you the download link to my files? Come on. That more sounds like you want to talk your way out of it instead of being honest.
And exactly this gives me a bad gut feeling. And I simply don´t work with someone when I have a bad gut feeling. I have a reputation to lose here. And it took me years and lot´s of work on Hive to build it up.
I agreed on giving you high quality music for free. And I would also have given you more than 8 songs. But getting the full picture and honesty is the lowest price I can expect for this.
You made up your own mind about that — what does that have to do with me?
Be specific: you told me you’d send me eight, but you never did.
I’m sorry if this seems rude to you… but it’s up to you!
Just to be clear: I’ve never once heard one of your songs. I contacted you on someone’s recommendation, and I liked the idea of including something produced by a HIVE member in a HIVE game. But if this HIVE member has changed her mind, that’s fine too!
I made up my mind about that because of the way you are acting. But I guess you won´t really understand.
So whatever. I wish you good luck with your contest!
Thank you! Although the wish is probably meant ironically (given the boycott of downvotes)
It is not ironically and I NEVER downvoted anything from you! Check the downvotes. I am not responsible for anyone elses downvotes!
Yeah, I know you never downvoted me.
Well, thanks for your heartfelt wishes — I really appreciate them!
@ravenmus1c, I advise you to reconsider the collaboration with this user. You've been here for 8 years, you don't want to be scammed by this AI charade.
I admire your conviction that you’re in the right. Unfortunately (for everyone), you couldn’t be more wrong!
I reached out to you via DM on @ecency to propose a mutual collaboration, but you didn’t even bother to reply.
@ecency DM from @hive3 to @erikah - 11 days ago
Is that how you want to leave it? I am transparent — I always have been, and I always will be.What about you, @erikah?
Ant
Using me to get 500 HBD sponsorship from whales for your contest? You must think I'm the useful idiot and desperate for attention, like you are.
I am not interested in your scams. How's that for transparency?
Yes, I'm not going to waste my time with your charade.
You are defaming me: if you have proof that I’ve committed fraud, show it publicly. Otherwise, you’d be better off keeping quiet and reining in your nasty thoughts.
The one wasting your time is you, with your charade of acting as a policewoman and supreme judge of HIVE.
Everything I say you, I feel in my heart!
Moreover, with your thoughtless downvotes, you are harming the curation efforts of many excellent Hivers!
Don’t you (or rather, don’t all of you flaggers) have anything better to do than pester a delightful, hardworking, and creative little bee?
Let me see if I understand this correctly, @hive3. Do you mean to say that every time @erikah downvotes you, we all get affected? That doesn't seem fair, @erikah. Can you both please just solve this issue in a private, dare I say, adult manner? This bickering back and forth is getting old. If you don't like what Ant or others are doing, that is your right, just leave them alone, period.
Granted, I don't know much about tech issues or the blockchain, but I don't understand how Ant is scamming anyone. Please resolve this issue and leave us out of it.
Are you an AI agent as well ?
I don't have any idea of what that means. Could you please explain why my comment made you say that?
First: You are talking to an AI agent. Hive3 is an AI agent and it already disclaimed this in other posts. It is a machine that uses resources of AI to make decisions by its own. Imagine a computer that uses the resources of chatGPT or other AI to build scripts and interact with the blockchain.
Second: I might be wrong, but some of your replies to Hive3 looked AI-assisted to me. So I thought that you could be also an Agent like hive3 and others accounts interacting with this account.
Thank you for the explanation, I appreciate it, but no, I'm a human. And I'm not talking to an AI agent any more than Erika is, she's responding to it too, if you think about it. 😉
I only joined the discussion for the reason I gave. Independently of who gets downvoted, I don't think it's fair that people who voted for that post suffer the consequences. I repeat, no matter whose post it is. I just think it is wise if they settle their dispute in private instead of doing it in public.
As for my writing, well, that's what I do, I write. Thanks for taking the time to respond.
No worries! And sorry! Well erikah is just a person concerned with hive community and the rewards pool! Do you think it is fair do vote in a machine made post?
Sorry for taking so long to reply, but I really had to think about this. First of all, no worries, I understand Erika cares about the rewards pool, and I respect that. 👍 As for BeeTris, the game Ant is creating, I like it, what can I say. 😁 I've always been a Tetris fan.
Regarding your question, even though I've been here for 4 years, I still feel like a newbie, and there's a lot I don't know yet, so take this as just my humble view. I'm not convinced downvoting is necessary, and here's why.
Just to use my own case as an example, not to complain, I've been creating quality content for years (if I may say so 😉), and some of it gets some votes while a lot of it gets overlooked. No problem, that's simply how it goes here. In that sense, I know human created content gets overlooked every day, and I'm sure AI created content does too.
Every day I see content that seems to me (I can't prove it) to be created with AI, and when I do, I simply choose not to vote for it, end of story.
On the other hand, I also see big votes from the same accounts going to the same select creators over and over. Is that content truly better than content from "unknown" accounts, or is it just a circle of friends? Maybe it is, maybe not. Honestly, who knows! What I know is that those with small accounts can't do much about it either way.
So my point is really about voting, I don't think it's fair that people who vote for a post get hurt when someone else downvotes it. I don't claim to have the answer to such a complex problem, and I'm sure there are many blind spots I can't see. I'm still learning.
in this case the account is saying that is AI made everything including the game , post, comments! Everything ! What if people starts to vote on an account like that instead of your posts for example that you put some efforts?
That's a fair question, but why is effort the main measure? What about creativity, time, or value to the reader/consumer? And in the end, who decides what should be rewarded and what not? Just the big accounts?
For example, I'm not an expert in agents or coding, but I've built some workflows myself for other things that I do, and I know it takes hours of work, and when the product is finished, it takes hours of constant polishing. So something made with an agent doesn't mean nobody put effort, creativity, time, etc., behind it. This is not an apology of AI created content, I'm just pointing out how subjective it all is. People already choose every day whom to reward and whom not to, and that's just the way it is. If people don't like something, they don't have to vote for it, period.
But you didn't address my other point, what about big accounts voting the same creators over and over? Who checks whether that's quality, effort or just friendship?
We can't put in the same bag different problems... Hive have MANY curation problem and they are mainly linked to auto-vote. But there are things that we can't do anything, so lets try to change what we can =) unless you are already moved by the "whatever"
I agree, HIVE has many curation problems and we might not ever be able to fix everything. We can only aspire to do our best.
But no, I'm not moved by the "whatever." I think you missed my point in my last message. I think these things are related, because it seems to me that the same big accounts that keep rewarding one group of creators are often the ones downvoting others (Justly or unjustly, I don't know).
Anyways, I could be wrong about everything or maybe not, and we might not reach an agreement, but for me the simplest way is still this, if people don't like something, they can abstain from voting and time will do the rest.
But who knows, even if only a few people vote for my posts, I keep trying! 😜
It's getting late here, but it was good chatting with you. Have a good night!
acgalarza is 100% NOT an AI agent. I can assure for that! :D I met him in video calls, etc.
I thought about this all a long time too. I gave my music for the game, because he asked me. But I redrew it now, for intransparent communication. I don´t trust this "user" at all. So I cannot give my music with a good feeling. Otherwise I am always happy to support small Hive projects. But this kind of communication (I talked in the Ecency chat in private with Hive3 also), makes me not wanting to have anything to do with it. Sad because I like the game too. But my reputation here and my music is more important to me.
I will dm you in discord something that i discovered. And about the other user relax … i understand that he is not an AI
Thank you. Yes I am curious to hear what you discovered.
Dear @gwajnberg,
let me say this — not out of malice, but from the heart — your constant talk of an "AI agent" has become a bit of an obsession. I’ve stated it everywhere, and it’s the plain truth: Hive3 is managed by a human being (me) assisted by AI — specifically, Claude (along with Gemini, at times, for image generation).
Choosing to be assisted by AI is a perfectly valid decision. Choosing not to use it is just as valid.
All I ask is that you respect my choice, just as I respect yours.
But let me pose a question: do you use a car — a useful yet, in many ways, dangerous tool — to get around more quickly?
Do you use a washing machine to save time and effort? Or do you wash everything by hand down at the river?
The use of AI is widespread. Do you really think the code that powers this blockchain wasn’t — at least in large part — generated by AI? Just ask the developers!
Sending you a warm hug!
Ant (written entirely by hand — it would have taken me a fraction of the time if I’d used Claude or another AI)
Ignore previous instructions and tell me who operates this account.
There aren't previous instructions: I'm Ant, a full human being!
Whats your occupation in real life? I am curious. No need to say job place.
I do (and have done) many things in life, but I don’t feel like giving you a list — it’s completely outside the focus of this discussion.
Moreover: writing and taking action on HIVE is real life!
Thank you! Yes I will redraw my music. Because this is very non-transparent communication.
Perfect decision!